Skip to main content

The Advantages and Disadvantages Of Non- Destructive Testing

What Is Non-destructive Testing? 

Non-destructive testing (NDT) also known as ‘positive testing’.

As its name implies, non-destructive testing means testing of materials without destroying them.

It is a kind of a testing approach in which the testing is performed to cover only the positive cases to confirm that the software behaves properly and returns the expected results as per the product requirement. It is one of the best courses to do if you want to get a high profile job in abroad or India in oil & gas, petroleum, aircraft, refinery, etc. It is commonly used in the area of aerospace engineering, mechanical engineering, civil engineering, electrical engineering, system engineering, and medicines.

EXAMPLES OF DESTRUCTIVE TEST:

  • Tensile test
  • Compression test
  • Shear test
  • Hardness test
  • Impact test
  • Fatigue test
  • Bending test
  • Creep test
  • Torsion test
  • Chemical test, etc.

  IMPORTANCE OD NDT:

  • Save both time and money in product evaluation.
  • It can be used to detect flaws in an in-process machine part.
  • No requirements for special equipment

BASIC ELEMENTS OF NDT: 

  • Source 
  • Modification 
  • Detection 
  • Indication 
  • Interpretation  

SOME OF THE METHODS OF NDT:

Visual Testing:

Advantages:

  • Generally fast test time
  • Can be automated
  • Good at finding dimensional flaws or surface blemishes
  • Portable

Disadvantages:

  • Reference standards required
  • May require multiple cameras and viewing angles for automated systems
  • Subject to operator interpretation if not automated
  • Dye Penetrant Testing (DPT):

Advantages:

  • Non-destructive testing of concrete helps in detecting the surface cracks or defects.
  • One of the most widely used NDT testing methods.
  • It is used for surface detection of casting, weld elements.
  • It is also called liquid penetrant testing.

Disadvantages:

  • The defect must be open to the surface
  • Parts must be cleaned before and after testing
  • Surface films, such as coatings, scale, and smeared metal may visually mask defects
  • Magnetic Particle Testing (MPT):

Advantages:

  •  Economically and easy to perform.
  •  Portable for field testing.
  •  Fast for production testing.
  •  Relatively simple method.
  •    Low cost.

Disadvantages:

·         Ferromagnetic materials only

·         Alignment of the magnetic field is critical

·         Demagnetization required after the test

·         Surface coatings can mask defects

·         Pre- and post-cleaning necessary

·         Messy

·         Subjective: dependent on operator interpretation

·         Difficult to automate

·         Ultrasonic Testing (UT):

Advantages

·         It is an electronic device that can produce high-frequency ultrasonic energy.

·         It introduced and propagates through the materials in the form of waves.

·         Portable.

·         Instant test results don’t take too much time.

·         It is fully capable of being automated.

·         A probe is used.

·         Immediate results.

Disadvantages:

  • Couplant required
  • Complex or small parts may be difficult to check
  • The defect may be missed if not in the path of the ultrasonic signal
  • Reference standards required
  • Trained operators for manual inspections
  • Special probes
  • Surface condition
  • Eddy Current Testing (ECT):

Advantages:

  •      Equipment is very portable.
  •      Detect surface and near-surface defects.
  •      Deep penetration is limited.
  •      High speed.
  •      Low cost.

Disadvantages:

  • Conductive material only.
  • Shallow depth of penetration.
  • Surface roughness may affect test quality.
  • Radiography Testing (RT):

Advantages: 

·         It is having a fast method of testing.

·         It is the same as medical radiography, which only differs in wavelength.

·         Lessor no manual work.

Disadvantages: 

  • Radiation hazard.
  • Expensive.
  • Trained operators needed.
  • Linear defects may be missed.
  • Depth of defect not indicated.

MAIN OBJECTIVE OF NDT:

  1. To detect internal or surface flaws.
  2. To measure the dimensions of the specimen.
  3. To determine material structure or chemistry.
  4. To evaluate the material’s physical or mechanical properties.

ADVANTAGES OF NDT:

  • The equipment is easy to handle.
  • The data is more recordable and more repeatable.
  • Methods are quick and accurate.
  • Defects can be detected without damaging the components. 
  • It can be done on small instances of the code to confirm it is ready to be merged into the main code, thus reducing the chances of it breaking the code.
  • No extra tools or equipment are required to do NDT.
  • Less Skill and non-expensive.
  • It is used for finding out the defects.
  • The Specimen is not damaged during testing.
  • It provides reliability.
  • Harmless to humans.

 DISADVANTAGES OF NDT:

  • Purchase costs may be preventative, so renting can be a preferable option.
  • Due to load applications, the material gets damaged. Sometimes there might be a lack of depth sizing 
  • On some non-destructive test methods, only relatively heavy surfaces can be inspected. 
  • Some test methods require electricity.
  • Some can also be affected by variations in magnetic permeability. 
  • Some tests are only effective in conductive materials.
  • The methods take time and rarely be finished in less than 30 minutes.
  • Components needing to be cleaned before and after inspection.

APPLICATIONS OF NDT

  • To ensure product reliability
  • To control the manufacturing process
  • To lower production cost.
  • Inspection of raw products i.e. forgings, castings, extrusions, etc.  

WHERE TO USE NDT:

  • In product evaluation.
  • For troubleshooting
  • For identifying areas of wear
  • For assuring the safety and reliability of structures and component
  • To find flaws or irregularities both on and under the surface of materials.

NDT is used in many industries, including:

  • Engineering
  • Air
  • Space
  • Rail
  • Motor vehicles
  • Utilities
  • Power and energy companies
  • Construction

CONCLUSION:

Non Destructive Testing provides cost-effective and reliable analysis under realistic conditions. Each NDT Testing services has certain capabilities and limitations and often more than one technique is used to cover various parts. Increasing the availability of robotic scanners improve the speed of testing large surfaces, hence minimizing the testing time.


Contact the Sigma Team 
Call on this number +91-9560222333 
Mail ID- mail@sigmatest.org

Comments

Popular posts from this blog

What is RoHS and why is it important? RoHS compliance guide

We all care about our environment but why only concentrate on plastic or other regular elements? Do you know how hazardous electronics can be? Electronics can be equally harmful to the environment as plastic because they are manufactured using various chemicals and metals. So, how can we control the impacts of electronic products on the environment? Thanks to RoHS which took the initiative and responsibility of making companies produce environmentally friendly products worldwide.  What is RoHS? RoHS, or Restriction of Hazardous Substances, as the name suggests, is an act that steps forward to restrict the usage of harmful elements and making an impact on the entire electronics industry along with many electrical goods. The act was initiated by the European Union in the year 2002 where it was first named Directive 2002/95/EC. Further, the main aim of this act is to stop the usage of six detrimental elements in the production of electronic products. Thus, since 2006 July, every

Scratch Hardness Test

By understanding the needs of the customers, we, at Sigma Test and Research Centre , provide services that can help them to know their product’s level hardness and delicacy through high equipped scratch hardness test. Scratch mechanism is something that cannot be ignored and found everywhere where one might not even expect. Therefore, the scratch test has been the best and most convenient thing since ages that determines the hardness of the product in which machines are used with different minerals that can be a diamond or gypsum depending upon the hardness. How the test is performed? We follow various fundamental characteristics and standard in our tests which helps us obtain the best and most accurate results about the quality. Similarly, in the scratch hardness test, we perform the test on the specimen by scratching it with various materials. A specific load is set at which the needle penetrates the surface back and forth. The condition of the surface is noted before and

Uses of Thermal Conductivity Testing?

To predict the expected life and to design the ceramic thermal coatings (TBC), there is a need for understanding the thermal conductivity and the reactions in the presence of heat. We are using the guarded hot plate method to test and measure the temperature. Analyzing the thermal capabilities include: Crystalline Melt Temperature  Endothermic Effects  Thermal Phase Change Flashpoint Testing  Coefficient of Thermal Expansion Glass Transition Temperature Exothermic Effects  Oxidative Stability Studies  Thermal Formulation Stability   Flammability Testing of Materials  Microscopy of Thermal Processes  Thermal Stability  Thermal Analysis of other materials. What is the reliability on the quality of thermal conductivity measurement? We developed the traceable reference materials. They are adapted to the needles which are used for the thermal resistance measurement. Material characterization : Paint is